Posted by
Tom Kummer on Monday, December 12, 2011 12:00:27 AM
I’ve made many comments on twitter about the end of the men’s basketball game between the Xavier Musketeers and Cincinnati Bearcats. Because it’s hard to post everything 140 characters at a time, I’m making this blog posting.
To see all of my tweets on the subject, please feel free to look at my twitter feed:
http://twitter.com/#!/Aquaman300. You’ll have to go back about 20+ tweets, so I will rehash what I said here, and discuss the penalties that were handed out to the Xavier players. Full disclosure, I am a Xavier alum, season ticket holder for men’s basketball for the past 20 years, and, according to the mailing the athletic department sends me every year, a booster for the Xavier athletic department. But I doubt the administration really cares what I think.
At the game on Dec. 10, I was sitting in the front row behind the broadcast team for Cincinnati. Those weren’t my usual seats, and how I came to have those seats is a story for another day. First, here is what I saw live. During the game, I had been sending out tweets about the progress of the game. After Tu Holloway scored with 20 seconds to go, I looked down to my phone to begin typing out a final score tweet. I glanced away from the action for a moment, and by the time I looked up, the fight had started.
My first image was seeing both benches empty, then Xavier center Kenny Frease was on all fours escaping the cluster of people. Frease also had a bloody left eye, stood up, walked to center court and collapsed. I also saw Xavier forward Dez Wells being restrained by a member of the Xavier staff. I caught a brief glance of Wells’ mouth, and it appeared bloody, but I haven’t seen any mention of him suffering an injury. Xavier forward Andre Walker was also being restrained, and I saw Xavier Athletic Director Mike Bobinski talking to Walker, asking him to calm down and saying that it will be alright. That was my best lip-reading that I could do.
Then when I was home, I had ample opportunity to watch replays of the brawl. This is how I saw it when watching the replay. With 9.4 seconds, the ball went out of bounds. A Cincinnati player (I couldn’t identify him) and Xavier’s Tu Holloway got in each other’s face and were shouting at each other. It then appeared that the Cincinnati player pushed Holloway. Dez Wells then pushed the Cincinnati player to the floor, and then all hell broke loose. Cincinnati’s Yancy Gates had the basketball in his hands and threw the ball, hitting Holloway. Gates also punched Kenny Frease, knocking him to the floor, where number 13 for Cincinnati proceeded to kick Frease. Xavier’s Mark Lyons and Landon Amos threw several punches. I also saw a Cincinnati player shove Xavier’s Brad Redford.
In this tweet yesterday, I said who should be suspended:
http://twitter.com/#!/Aquaman300/status/145641045965799424. Landon Amos was the player I couldn’t identify. The suspensions were announced today, and it came down about as I expected. Wells and Amos received 4 games, meaning they will miss the Hawaii trip. Lyons gets 2 games, and Holloway 1. I believe the suspensions are appropriate for what happened.
As an alum, fan and ticket holder of Xavier, the brawl at the end of the game is an embarrassment. The actions of those involved reflect poorly on the team and the university. Also reprehensible was the student section, chanting “F--- UC”. Such a chant has no place in collegiate athletics, let alone at a Catholic university like Xavier. In response to the events of yesterday, Xavier and the Atlantic 10 conference has taken the appropriate action. Several players for Xavier have apologized over twitter, and Holloway also apologized at a press conference today. It is all of our hopes that the Xavier players can put this behind them and once again conduct themselves in a manner appropriate to a Xavier student-athlete.