Posted by
Tom Kummer on Saturday, November 01, 2008 11:42:44 AM
On the website www.republicansforobama.org, a case is made that Senator Obama will unite the country, which will result in a number of major issues being addressed. I will address those issues one at a time and ask specifically how an Obama administration will solve these problems.
1) The National Debt.
Everyone agrees that it’s a problem, but there is a lack of political will to do anything about it. Furthermore, how will this get better under an Obama administration, when he is proposing additional new spending programs? Are there spending programs that he’s going to cut? You can’t call tax increases spending reductions, so don’t give me that one.
2) Trade Deficit
Even if we accept this as a problem, what specifically has Senator Obama proposed that will reduce this? Does he support higher import tariffs? All that does is raise the cost of goods, which will harm the very middle class he purports to help.
3) Energy Independence
One way to help with this is to drill in ANWR and expand drilling off-shore, both proposals Senator Obama is against. You mention increased support for nuclear power from environmentalists, but Senator Obama is against that, too. Iowa corn? Is that really feasible? It currently takes more energy to produce ethanol from corn than that ethanol provides. Ethanol derived from sugar, that’s another story, but high import tariffs on sugar prevent us from doing that. Maybe Senator Obama will reduce or eliminate those tariffs, but that would run afoul of the plans for the trade deficit. Will you still support him then?
4) Global Warming
Historically the earth has been warmer than it is now and colder than it is now. If global warming is a natural occurrence, what can we do to stop nature? Scientists by no means agree that it is mad made, nor is there agreement that it’s going to be a catastrophe. Bjorn Lomborg has studied this issue in-depth, and, while he does think that human activity is contributing to it, there is simply not enough data to prove that this is the case. Based on that, is it prudent to spend a lot of tax payer money to solve something that may not be a problem? Won’t that run afoul of the national debt?
5) Social Security
You state that “We need a reliable, sustainable retirement plan that combines mandatory retirement savings with flexibility, choice, and security”. Has Senator Obama proposed any plan for Social Security that has any of those qualities, other than the mandatory retirement savings? (As an aside, I find it odd for anyone who calls himself “Pro-choice” to be in favor of any mandatory retirement savings program. Shouldn’t I have the right to choose my own retirement plan? Or even choose not to save for retirement? But that’s an issue for another day.) You also state that Social Security and Medicare benefits must be quickly trimmed, but is Senator Obama proposing that? I don’t think so. He bashed John McCain for wanting to cut Medicare.
6) Healthcare Reform.
You state that businesses are being crippled by rising costs, but Senator Obama wants to further entrench employer provided health coverage. Is that really the way to achieve your goals? The best way to do that, it seems to me, is to end the bias that the tax code has in favor of employer provided health insurance, which is a relic of World War II. John McCain’s proposal for this, a $2500/$5000 (individuals/families) tax credit for the purchase of health coverage, while taxing employer provided health coverage, will do this. In order to bring down health care costs, the person who receives the care must bear some of the costs. (High-deductible healthcare plans have a lot of potential there, an innovation of the Bush administration, which is one of the best things he’s done.)
Also, on health coverage, to truly reform the system, it has to become portable. Too many people are tied to jobs they hate because of health insurance. Strengthening employer provided health insurance will do nothing to get us closer to portability, and will only move us further away from that.
7) Tax reform
I strongly agree that our tax code is inefficient, but what has Senator Obama proposed that will make it more efficient? You get more tax credits, but is that more efficient? Also, Senator Obama criticizes John McCain for wanting to lower the corporate tax rate, when that is one of the things that stands in the way of businesses starting and locating here, and also businesses expanding
8) Immigration Reform
While this is important, has Senator Obama proposed anything specific on this?
9) Foreign Policy
Our foreign policy must be based on strength, not weakness. For example, the President of Iran has stated that Israel should be wiped off the map. How does meeting with someone like this, as Senator Obama says he would, without preconditions, show anything but weakness? How can you negotiate with someone like that? Do you say something like “Gee, how about only wiping out half of Israel”?
So considering all this, what does Senator Obama propose that will solve these important issues? Why should Republicans, who would agree that these are important issues, vote for Senator Obama? What specifically about his plan entices those Republicans who support him to do so?